How many fit
10 of the 23 models checked meet every need here: “Ordinary bullet ice does the job for me”, “I want my first ice in a hurry”, and “I don't have much counter room”.
10 models fit, out of 23 checkedPicked for one job
For simple bullet ice, Frigidaire EFIC189 fits best
Top pick
Frigidaire Compact Ice Maker
EFIC189 is compact and fast, and it has been independently tested. Silonn SLIM01B adds self-cleaning, while Whynter IMC-491DC handles much heavier demand.
Why it suits this job
- Initial batch
- Footprint
- The catch
- Independent testing found the two bullet sizes close to each other in practice.
- Go with Silonn Countertop Bullet Ice Maker if
- Compact bullet ice on a budget, with a cleaning cycle
More reasons we picked it
- Sizes offered
- Drain reach
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
Quick everyday ice, minus the cost of nugget machinery.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the countertop ice makers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
How we countedThe count uses each product's current fit ratings for “Ordinary bullet ice does the job for me”, “I want my first ice in a hurry”, and “I don't have much counter room”. A need with no documented match is not counted.
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Frigidaire Compact Ice Maker |
|
| |
| Silonn Countertop Bullet Ice Maker |
|
| |
| Whynter 49 lb Portable Ice Maker |
|
|
|
3 options
The top pick and the alternatives
Frigidaire, EFIC189-Silver
Compact Ice Maker
Simple controls, two sizes and one of the smallest footprints in the set come with this proven 26-pound bullet maker.
Top pick ifQuick, no-fuss everyday ice that does not cost much
Key facts
- Frigidaire's rating for the machine is 26 pounds of ice per day.
- First ice came in under seven minutes, as measured by Popular Mechanics.
The catch
Independent testing found the two bullet sizes close to each other in practice.
Silonn, SLIM01B
Countertop Bullet Ice Maker
This 26-pound bullet maker is widely sold, with two sizes, one-touch cleaning and a six-minute first cycle.
Best forCompact bullet ice on a budget, with a cleaning cycle
Key facts
- Silonn's listing gives 26 pounds per day and nine bullets in six minutes.
- Two selectable bullet sizes are fed by a two-liter water tank.
The catch
Ice melts in the compact basket unless you use it or move it to a freezer.
Whynter, IMC-491DC
49 lb Portable Ice Maker
The highest daily rating in the set belongs to this large bullet machine, which also has a five-liter tank, three sizes and an optional direct water connection.
Best forBullet ice at high output over long stretches, with less refilling
Key facts
- Whynter's production rating is 49 pounds per day, with storage of 2.7 pounds.
- You can fill the five-liter tank by hand or through the included 12-foot direct-water hose.
The catch
Side handles notwithstanding, a 32-pound body and 17-inch depth mean it is going to stay on the counter.
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Top pick for this job
Frigidaire Compact Ice Maker
Initial batch
See price & reviews on AmazonPick this instead if
Silonn Countertop Bullet Ice Maker
Compact bullet ice on a budget, with a cleaning cycle
See price & reviews on AmazonWe may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money