The catch
Gaggia Magenta Plus
No profile system for four users.
Side by side
Gaggia Magenta Plus vs Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus compared: Milk still needs manual steaming on both, Cadorna saves four profiles
Quick verdict
A narrower body and larger water and waste containers, if they matter more to you than saved household profiles, favor Magenta Plus. Up to four people wanting to recall their settings favor Cadorna Barista Plus. Manual steam wands are used on both, so Cadorna’s profiles do not turn a latte into a one-touch milk drink.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
One machine has to serve several coffee preferences
Say one person wants a short, strong coffee and another changes its volume and strength. Cadorna's four profiles can keep those settings separate. Magenta gives you adjustable drinks but not that four-user structure. The benefit stops at the recipe controls, because both machines still have one bean hopper and manual steam hardware. Saved preferences do not switch beans or automate the milk portion of a latte.
Where this comes from
Cadorna is documented with four profiles, and manual steam wands are listed for both models. Profile memory implies no automatic bean-change or one-touch milk capability.
The catch
Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
A body that is wider and taller, with smaller service containers.
Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Why pick it
- Narrow enough for you means the 8.8-inch body.
- The larger 1.8-liter tank and 15-puck waste container are your preference.
- The catch
- No profile system for four users.
Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Why pick it
- Four saved user profiles are what you want.
- Ristretto on the shared coffee menu and ten grind settings are what you want.
- The catch
- A body that is wider and taller, with smaller service containers.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
Saved household profiles go up against a narrower body and larger service containers, and both manual milk workflows stay clear.
This one comes down to user profiles and named recipes first, then to the limits of your own setup.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
Saved settings are wanted by four people
Four profiles come with the Cadorna.
- Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Good
- Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Better fit
You have less than 10.2 inches of width available
Access requirements still apply even though Magenta is 8.8 inches wide.
- Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Depends
- Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Caution
Larger service containers are your preference
The larger tank and waste bin belong to the Magenta.
- Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Better fit
- Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Good
One-touch milk drinks are what you want
Manual steam wands are used on both selected versions.
- Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Caution
- Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Caution
In practice
Differences you will notice
One machine has to serve several coffee preferences
Say one person wants a short, strong coffee and another changes its volume and strength. Cadorna's four profiles can keep those settings separate. Magenta gives you adjustable drinks but not that four-user structure. The benefit stops at the recipe controls, because both machines still have one bean hopper and manual steam hardware. Saved preferences do not switch beans or automate the milk portion of a latte.
How we worked this out
Cadorna is documented with four profiles, and manual steam wands are listed for both models. Profile memory implies no automatic bean-change or one-touch milk capability.
A narrow coffee station can outweigh a preference for profiles
Take a hypothetical opening 9.5 inches wide. Magenta's 8.8-inch body is narrower than that opening, whereas Cadorna's 10.2-inch body exceeds it. That rules out Cadorna for that opening before service access is even considered. Magenta still needs whatever space its operating instructions require for filling and cleaning. Its larger tank and waste bin may also be convenient, but those numbers do not prove a specific number of days between maintenance.
How we worked this out
The opening is a scenario the buyer defines. The body-width arithmetic is 9.5 minus 8.8 equals 0.7 inch, and 10.2 exceeds 9.5 by 0.7 inch. It does not approve installation clearance.
A bigger waste bin does not dictate a hygiene schedule
Cadorna's 10 puck spaces are five fewer than the nominal spaces in Magenta's 15-puck bin. That may delay an emptying prompt triggered by capacity, but cleaning should still follow the manual.
How we worked this out
The calculation is about container capacity and nothing else. Moist grounds, rinsing and user routines make a reliable prediction of days between cleanings impossible.
Option A
Gaggia, RI8700/46
Magenta Plus
A proper manual steam wand sits alongside automatic espresso preparation, for buyers who still like pouring milk.
- Best for
- Narrow enough for you means the 8.8-inch body.
Facts we checked
- Profiles for users: No four-user profile system
- Recipes by name: Espresso, Espresso Lungo, Coffee, Americano and Hot Water
- Preparing milk: A manual steam wand in commercial style
- Body size: 8.8 W × 17.1 D × 14 H inches
Option B
Gaggia, Cadorna Barista Plus US
Cadorna Barista Plus
Each person steams their own milk with the manual wand, while the coffee recipe is taken care of by saved profiles.
- Best for
- Four saved user profiles are what you want.
Facts we checked
- Profiles for users: 4 user profiles
- Recipes by name: The same five, with Ristretto added
- Preparing milk: A manual steam wand in commercial style
- Body size: 10.2 W × 17.3 D × 15 H inches
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Gaggia Magenta Plus | Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| User profiles | No four-user profile system | 4 user profiles | Household drink settings can be kept separate on the Cadorna. |
| Named recipes | Espresso, Espresso Lungo, Coffee, Americano, Hot Water | Those five plus Ristretto | The added recipe brings something specific. It is not a general move into automatic milk drinks. |
| Milk preparation | Manual commercial-style steam wand | Manual commercial-style steam wand | User milk technique is still required on both. |
| Body dimensions | 8.8 W × 17.1 D × 14 H inches | 10.2 W × 17.3 D × 15 H inches | Before access space, Cadorna is 1.4 inches wider and 1 inch taller. |
| Water tank and waste bin | 1.8 liters and 15 pucks | 1.5 liters and 10 pucks | The larger service containers are on the Magenta, which does not establish a refill schedule. |
| Grind settings | 5 | 10 | More adjustment positions come with the Cadorna, though that does not prove a cup-quality advantage. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Gaggia Magenta Plus
- Cadorna's ten grinder positions against five.
With Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
- Profiles bring neither milk automation nor bean changes.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
The daily pain point is saved user settings
Go with Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus. Four user profiles fit on Cadorna.
The firm constraint is counter width
Go with Gaggia Magenta Plus. The Magenta body is narrower by 1.4 inches.
Decision guide
How to decide
Magenta Plus is the machine for you if a narrower body and larger water and waste containers outweigh saved household profiles. Cadorna Barista Plus is for when up to four people want to recall their settings. Because both use manual steam wands, Cadorna’s profiles do not turn a latte into a one-touch milk drink.
Profiles fit different people better than different beans
Cadorna’s memory helps when users vary drink settings but share a hopper. Switching between regular and decaf beans is not something it solves by itself.
Look at the body before you plan the station
In a tight spot, Magenta’s body is 1.4 inches narrower and 1 inch shorter, and that can matter. Even so, check separately that you can remove the tank, give the machine ventilation and reach the parts you clean.
Don’t mix up the Plus variants
Both Magenta Plus and Cadorna Barista Plus come with manual milk hardware. Any automatic carafe feature belongs to other Magenta or Cadorna variants and has no place in this comparison.
What this page can’t tell you
- There is no side-by-side test of espresso, steaming or cleaning. Bigger tanks and bins also say nothing about how often maintenance is due.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the espresso machines we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gaggia Magenta Plus |
|
|
|
| Gaggia Cadorna Barista Plus |
|
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Gaggia Magenta Plus
Narrow enough for you means the 8.8-inch body.
See price & reviews on AmazonGaggia Cadorna Barista Plus
Four saved user profiles are what you want.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money