The catch
Brother HL-L5210DW
On a long job with ordinary paper, the main tray may need refilling even if you collect the output regularly.
Side by side
Brother HL-L5210DW vs HL-L6210DW: Both need output collected, 6210 needs fewer refills
Quick verdict
The HL-L6210DW is the one if its 520-sheet main tray saves you a regular paper refill or your routine workload goes above 5,000 pages a month, within its 8,000-page recommendation. The HL-L5210DW fits when a 250-sheet main tray is enough and you prefer a lower, lighter body. Face-down output holds 150 sheets on both, so the bigger input does not turn a 500-sheet run into an unattended one.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
On either printer, a 500-sheet job still means collecting the output
Say you are printing 500 single-sided handouts to prepare for a class or meeting. The 6210 main tray takes all the paper in one load, while the 5210 main tray needs two. Both output bins, however, hold only 150 ordinary sheets, so on either machine you have to collect pages during the run. The reason to buy the 6210 is to skip the input refill and not to walk away from the whole job. If you print those 500 pages duplex, the sheet count drops to 250 and the input advantage changes.
Where this comes from
With 20 lb paper, 500 single-sided pages take 500 sheets. Main-tray loads work out to ceiling(500/520) = 1 and ceiling(500/250) = 2. Both printers produce ceiling(500/150) = 4 output batches, which means at least three interim collections. When 500 pages print duplex, 250 sheets fit either main tray. The MP tray is kept for alternate stock.
The catch
Brother HL-L6210DW
Output bin size stays the same despite the larger main tray. The body is 1.3 inches higher and 5.7 lb heavier.
Brother HL-L5210DW
- Why pick it
- A body 1.3 inches lower is an option when a 250-sheet main tray covers the usual job.
- You can skip the larger model if routine volume stays within 5,000 pages and refill trips are rare.
- The catch
- On a long job with ordinary paper, the main tray may need refilling even if you collect the output regularly.
Brother HL-L6210DW
- Why pick it
- The main tray takes up to 520 ordinary sheets, though you still collect output at its 150-sheet limit.
- Body width and depth stay the same, with more paper supplied as standard.
- The catch
- Output bin size stays the same despite the larger main tray. The body is 1.3 inches higher and 5.7 lb heavier.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
More paper fits in the HL-L6210DW within the same footprint, yet output holds at 150 sheets. Compare refills, cabinet height and what comes in the box.
These are neighboring Brother business monochrome print-only models, with the same base dimensions and the usual network connections. What a buyer really has to work out is whether the larger paper supply changes the daily job enough to justify the upgrade.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
Single-sided 500-sheet jobs are frequent and use the main tray
The 6210 spares you the input refill. Both still need output collected partway.
- Brother HL-L5210DW
- Caution
- Brother HL-L6210DW
- Better fit
Those 500 printed pages normally print on both sides
It comes to 250 sheets, and either main tray holds that at the stated paper weight.
- Brother HL-L5210DW
- Good
- Brother HL-L6210DW
- Good
You routinely print 6,000 pages a month
That is over the 5,000 recommended maximum of the 5210 and within the 8,000 of the 6210.
- Brother HL-L5210DW
- Caution
- Brother HL-L6210DW
- Better fit
A lower body matters to you and typical jobs fit within 250 sheets
The 5210 stands 1.3 inches lower. Before putting either under a shelf, check operating clearance.
- Brother HL-L5210DW
- Better fit
- Brother HL-L6210DW
- Depends
In practice
Differences you will notice
On either printer, a 500-sheet job still means collecting the output
Say you are printing 500 single-sided handouts to prepare for a class or meeting. The 6210 main tray takes all the paper in one load, while the 5210 main tray needs two. Both output bins, however, hold only 150 ordinary sheets, so on either machine you have to collect pages during the run. The reason to buy the 6210 is to skip the input refill and not to walk away from the whole job. If you print those 500 pages duplex, the sheet count drops to 250 and the input advantage changes.
How we worked this out
With 20 lb paper, 500 single-sided pages take 500 sheets. Main-tray loads work out to ceiling(500/520) = 1 and ceiling(500/250) = 2. Both printers produce ceiling(500/150) = 4 output batches, which means at least three interim collections. When 500 pages print duplex, 250 sheets fit either main tray. The MP tray is kept for alternate stock.
Height is the price of the larger paper supply, not extra worktop area
A shared office might have plenty of floor or worktop space but little clearance beneath a shelf. Both printers share the same 14.7 by 15.3-inch base dimensions. The 6210 is 1.3 inches taller when closed and 5.7 lb heavier. If you seldom have to refill the 5210 mid-job, its lower body can be the better fit. If you refill every day and have the height to spare, the 6210 adds capacity without getting wider or deeper.
How we worked this out
11.4 - 10.1 = 1.3 inches and 29.8 - 24.1 = 5.7 lb. Operating and ventilation clearance is not part of the closed dimensions. The packages compared are the standard single-tray DW ones. DWT packages are left out.
The large replacement-toner figure has no effect on what comes in the first box
If you are upgrading to avoid buying toner early, look at the cartridge that ships in the box. Both standard boxes include TN920 with the same 3,000-page ISO claim. The higher-capacity replacement for the 6210 comes later and is bought separately. It can still suit an office with sustained high volume, but a light-use home office does not start out with six times as much toner. Compare current complete costs before the replacement-yield headline makes the decision for you.
How we worked this out
Each ships with a 3,000-page ISO19752 TN920. The HL6210 can also take an optional 18,000-page-rated replacement. No current cartridge cost, household yield or saving on ownership cost is assumed.
Option A
Brother, HL-L5210DW
HL-L5210DW
A body 1.3 inches lower is an option when a 250-sheet main tray covers the usual job.
- Best for
- A body 1.3 inches lower is an option when a 250-sheet main tray covers the usual job.
Facts we checked
- Main-tray print supply: 250-sheet main tray plus 100-sheet multipurpose tray. Face-down output holds 150 sheets, based on 20 lb paper.
- Cabinet and worktop fit: Closed body 14.7 x 15.3 x 10.1 inches and weight 24.1 lb.
- Supplied versus replacement toner: Includes TN920 rated at 3,000 ISO19752 pages. Higher-yield replacements are optional.
- Sustained workload: Recommended monthly maximum 5,000 pages.
Option B
Brother, HL-L6210DW
HL-L6210DW
The main tray takes up to 520 ordinary sheets, though you still collect output at its 150-sheet limit.
- Best for
- The main tray takes up to 520 ordinary sheets, though you still collect output at its 150-sheet limit.
Facts we checked
- Main-tray print supply: The standard HL-L6210DW has a 520-sheet main tray plus 100-sheet multipurpose tray. Face-down output holds 150 sheets at 20 lb.
- Cabinet and worktop fit: Closed body 14.7 x 15.3 x 11.4 inches and weight 29.8 lb. This is the DW single-tray model.
- Supplied versus replacement toner: Includes TN920 rated at 3,000 ISO19752 pages. An 18,000-page replacement is available separately.
- Sustained workload: Recommended monthly maximum 8,000 pages.
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Brother HL-L5210DW | Brother HL-L6210DW | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main-tray print supply | 250-sheet main tray plus 100-sheet multipurpose tray. Face-down output holds 150 sheets, based on 20 lb paper. | The standard HL-L6210DW has a 520-sheet main tray plus 100-sheet multipurpose tray. Face-down output holds 150 sheets at 20 lb. | Bigger input cuts refills, but equal output limits keep the collection trips. |
| Cabinet and worktop fit | Closed body 14.7 x 15.3 x 10.1 inches and weight 24.1 lb. | Closed body 14.7 x 15.3 x 11.4 inches and weight 29.8 lb. This is the DW single-tray model. | The upgrade has the same footprint and needs more vertical space. Leave room for loading paper and for maintenance. |
| Supplied versus replacement toner | Includes TN920 rated at 3,000 ISO19752 pages. Higher-yield replacements are optional. | Includes TN920 rated at 3,000 ISO19752 pages. An 18,000-page replacement is available separately. | Do not treat the standard package as if the largest replacement cartridge came with it. |
| Sustained workload | Recommended monthly maximum 5,000 pages. | Recommended monthly maximum 8,000 pages. | It matters for a workload that repeats. It does not mean either printer fails right away once you go beyond the recommendation. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Brother HL-L5210DW
- More input means buying a lower tray separately and giving up more height.
With Brother HL-L6210DW
- A 3,000-page-rated TN920 is what the standard DW box includes. The 18,000-page replacement cartridge is not the cartridge supplied.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
Typical jobs fit the main tray and the lower body helps
Go with Brother HL-L5210DW. The 5210 spares you from buying capacity that removes no regular refill.
Single-sided runs keep going past 250 sheets, or sustained volume tops 5,000 a month
Go with Brother HL-L6210DW. Those specific capacity and workload limits are what the 6210 addresses.
A 500-sheet job has to complete with nobody collecting the output
Neither model fits. The documented output bin on each holds 150 sheets.
Decision guide
Before you buy
Printing a long packet while you work on something else is the goal, but a larger input tray may fix refills and still leave you collecting printed sheets.
What this page can’t tell you
- Because the current 6210 brochure link leads to a DWT file, facts about the DW package come from the exact US product specification.
- No ranking for measured speed or cost per page.
- Capacity figures assume supported 20 lb stock, and they do not promise unattended feeding.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the laser printers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brother HL-L5210DW |
|
| |
| Brother HL-L6210DW |
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Brother HL-L5210DW
A body 1.3 inches lower is an option when a 250-sheet main tray covers the usual job.
You can skip the larger model if routine volume stays within 5,000 pages and refill trips are rare.
See price & reviews on AmazonBrother HL-L6210DW
The main tray takes up to 520 ordinary sheets, though you still collect output at its 150-sheet limit.
Body width and depth stay the same, with more paper supplied as standard.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money