The catch
Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
Retrieving the original model from the bottom takes a hook and a separately supplied pool pole.
Side by side
Aiper Scuba S1 (2024) vs Scuba V3 Compared: A fine filter and brief waterline pickup are what V3 adds
Quick verdict
V3 is the choice when its included fine filter, dock and timed waterline pickup fix specific frustrations. V3 adds an included three-micron insert and a ten-minute waterline collection window. Keep the original S1 in the running if hook retrieval and its local Eco schedule are enough, especially when the shorter four-hour specified charge matters. By its exact manual, V3 takes five hours. Neither schedule amounts to a week of continuous cleaning or filter-free care.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
You only get rid of the pole with the upgrade if you catch the window
Original S1 relies on a hook attached to a separately supplied pool pole. V3 can bring its handle to the waterline for ten minutes and then goes back to the bottom. If you can time the finish around a coffee break, that can take away an awkward reaching task. If you are away at work or interrupted regularly, the same upgrade may still end with a pole. V3 also loses app communication underwater, so a phone is not a reliable way to recall it after you have missed collection.
Where this comes from
Original bottom retrieval versus timed waterline retrieval, set against predictable or unpredictable availability. No unsupported mobility or injury benefit is claimed.
The catch
Aiper Scuba V3
If you miss the ten-minute window you are back to bottom retrieval, and the fine insert brings prompt rinsing and replacement.
Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- Why pick it
- Using a pool pole is fine with you, and the original local Eco floor program suits the job.
- The documented four-hour charge helps you, and you have no established need for what V3 adds.
- The catch
- Retrieving the original model from the bottom takes a hook and a separately supplied pool pole.
Aiper Scuba V3
- Why pick it
- You can stay close during the waterline window and want the fine insert and dock that come included.
- A real need is met by supported camera-assisted floor modes and more configurable short floor visits.
- The catch
- If you miss the ten-minute window you are back to bottom retrieval, and the fine insert brings prompt rinsing and replacement.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
Original Aiper Scuba S1 vs Scuba V3 on scheduled floor visits, fine dirt and easier pickup. Confirm the revision and note the work an upgrade still leaves.
For owners who want fewer pool chores, the decision is between the original model and the newer premium family. Keep the exact 2024 S1 apart from later S1 listings that have different features.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
You can collect it promptly and would like to skip routine hook retrieval
A ten-minute waterline window comes with V3.
- Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- Caution
- Aiper Scuba V3
- Better fit
Pole retrieval and local Eco cleaning already do the job well
Original S1 has the shorter specified charge and fits that routine.
- Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- Better fit
- Aiper Scuba V3
- Caution
The complaint nobody has resolved is fine settled dirt
Extra care is required with the verified fine insert that V3 includes.
- Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- Caution
- Aiper Scuba V3
- Better fit
A week away with a heavy leaf load
Scheduling will not empty the basket or inspect conditions.
- Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- Caution
- Aiper Scuba V3
- Caution
In practice
Differences you will notice
You only get rid of the pole with the upgrade if you catch the window
Original S1 relies on a hook attached to a separately supplied pool pole. V3 can bring its handle to the waterline for ten minutes and then goes back to the bottom. If you can time the finish around a coffee break, that can take away an awkward reaching task. If you are away at work or interrupted regularly, the same upgrade may still end with a pole. V3 also loses app communication underwater, so a phone is not a reliable way to recall it after you have missed collection.
How we worked this out
Original bottom retrieval versus timed waterline retrieval, set against predictable or unpredictable availability. No unsupported mobility or injury benefit is claimed.
Actual cleaning can be surprisingly scarce in a calendar week
On a full charge, the Eco program on S1 does a 45-minute floor visit every 48 hours for a week. V3 offers floor schedules of four 45-minute, three 60-minute or two 90-minute visits, and every V3 option adds up to 180 scheduled minutes. These modes spread a finite budget over several days, and the V3 manual limits scheduled use to minimal debris. If trees shed heavily while you are away, neither calendar feature is a sound substitute for checking basket loading and arranging maintenance.
How we worked this out
Each of 4 × 45, 3 × 60 and 2 × 90 comes to 180 minutes. Exact scheduled modes, set against absence and heavy debris. No count of S1 visits is inferred, and full rated runtime in every pool is not guaranteed.
After the run, fine filtering gives you a reason to come back
For fine debris after coarse cleanup, V3 includes the three-micron insert. If small settled dirt is what disappoints you about the current routine, that is a useful improvement to the package. It also brings prompt filter rinsing and Aiper’s 30-use replacement instruction. The robot then has a five-hour specified charge, against four hours for original S1. Think of the upgrade as a different cleanup routine, with finer filtering and easier timely retrieval, and not as an automatic cut in every maintenance task.
How we worked this out
Included consumable fine filter and charge times, set against a fine-dirt complaint and a wish to cut down on hands-on work. Fine-accessory compatibility for original S1 remains unverified.
Option A
Aiper, Scuba S1, original 2024
Scuba S1 (2024)
Using a pool pole is fine with you, and the original local Eco floor program suits the job.
- Best for
- Using a pool pole is fine with you, and the original local Eco floor program suits the job.
Facts we checked
- Retrieval: Bottom hook, pool pole not included
- Scheduled floor work: 45 minutes every 48 hours for one week from full charge
- Rated runtime and charge: Up to 150 minutes, four-hour charge
- Selected fine-filter package: Original standard kit, 3-micron insert not verified
Option B
Aiper, PRN31
Scuba V3
You can stay close during the waterline window and want the fine insert and dock that come included.
- Best for
- You can stay close during the waterline window and want the fine insert and dock that come included.
Facts we checked
- Retrieval: Ten-minute waterline window, then bottom
- Scheduled floor work: Four 45-minute, three 60-minute or two 90-minute floor visits
- Rated runtime and charge: 180 minutes, five-hour charge
- Selected fine-filter package: 3-micron MicroMesh insert included
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Aiper Scuba S1 (2024) | Aiper Scuba V3 | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retrieval | Bottom hook, pool pole not included | Ten-minute waterline window, then bottom | Timely collection gets better with the upgrade, but not every delayed pickup does. |
| Scheduled floor work | 45 minutes every 48 hours for one week from full charge | Four 45-minute, three 60-minute or two 90-minute floor visits | Read the calendar label together with the total cleaning budget. |
| Rated runtime and charge | Up to 150 minutes, four-hour charge | 180 minutes, five-hour charge | A longer specified recharge comes with a longer rated run. |
| Selected fine-filter package | Original standard kit, 3-micron insert not verified | 3-micron MicroMesh insert included | V3’s included fine option is established, and that does not assume every S1 accessory is impossible. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
- App and filter claims from later S1 revisions do not carry over to this 2024 S1.
With Aiper Scuba V3
- The app disconnects underwater. Expect five-hour charging and a 30-use fine-insert replacement instruction.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
What is missing is a benefit for fine dirt and timely pole-free collection
Go with Aiper Scuba V3. The fine insert and waterline window are what V3 adds.
Recharge time matters and the local Eco routine already fits
Go with Aiper Scuba S1 (2024). Original S1 has the shorter specified full charge and does not require the new routine.
Decision guide
Before you buy
You want to move on from pole retrieval and repeated floor cleanup without taking on a new set of maintenance chores.
What this page can’t tell you
- There is no measured ranking for cleaning or reliability. Both manuals prohibit use with swimmers or animals, and they require other pool equipment to be off as directed.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the robot pool cleaners we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Aiper Scuba S1 (2024) |
|
| |
| Aiper Scuba V3 |
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Aiper Scuba S1 (2024)
Using a pool pole is fine with you, and the original local Eco floor program suits the job.
The documented four-hour charge helps you, and you have no established need for what V3 adds.
See price & reviews on AmazonAiper Scuba V3
You can stay close during the waterline window and want the fine insert and dock that come included.
A real need is met by supported camera-assisted floor modes and more configurable short floor visits.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money