The catch
Brother HL-L8430CDW
It has no scanner, so it cannot digitize a signed packet or copy a book on its own.
Side by side
Brother HL-L8430CDW vs MFC-L8730CDW: HL fits more optional paper, MFC adds scanning and height
Quick verdict
If scanning is already covered and you want a lower printer or more optional paper capacity, the HL-L8430CDW is the one. The MFC-L8730CDW makes sense when a built-in flatbed and 80-sheet duplex feeder can stand in for a separate scanner. The body footprint is the same 15.9 by 18.6-inch on both, and so is the 33-ppm rated color printing. What the MFC adds is 4.8 inches of body height, and not a faster print engine.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
Dropping the scanner saves height but leaves the printer’s footprint the same
With a printer under an open shelf, HL-L8430CDW takes 4.8 inches off the closed-body height of MFC-L8730CDW. Width and depth stay the same, though. If you already own a scanner, it is a sensible way to avoid doubling up on a lid and a feeder. If your separate scanner takes up another part of the desk, the MFC may shrink the combined equipment footprint instead. Measure both complete setups.
Where this comes from
Both bodies measure 15.9 by 18.6 inches. The height difference is 18.1 - 13.3 = 4.8 inches. Since the area of any existing separate scanner is unknown, no net saving in desktop space is claimed.
The catch
Brother MFC-L8730CDW
With the scanner come extra height and weight. Per the US specification, optional input reaches at most 800 sheets, against 1,340 for the HL.
Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Why pick it
- A body 4.8 inches lower is yours when a separate scanner already does the job.
- Input can grow to a documented 1,340 sheets with trays bought separately.
- The catch
- It has no scanner, so it cannot digitize a signed packet or copy a book on its own.
Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Why pick it
- An 80-sheet one-pass duplex feeder can take the place of a separate document scanner, within its paper limits.
- Eligible book pages get copied on the flatbed, with room for the lid to open.
- The catch
- With the scanner come extra height and weight. Per the US specification, optional input reaches at most 800 sheets, against 1,340 for the HL.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
The desk footprint is identical. Weigh scanner height, optional tray capacity and the jobs that justify an all-in-one over a print-only machine.
When replacing a color office printer, you can pick the print-only model and keep the scanner you already have, or fold both jobs into a single footprint. They also expand differently, so this is more than a feature checklist.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
An existing separate scanner covers all the required originals
HL skips the duplicate scanning hardware and sits lower.
- Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Better fit
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Depends
Signed loose packets and book pages have to be captured right at the printer
The MFC provides both the feeder and the glass, so keep their size and media limits in mind.
- Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Not suitable
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Better fit
You plan optional paper input of more than 800 sheets
HL goes up to 1,340 with optional trays, against a documented total of 800 for the MFC.
- Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Better fit
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Not suitable
Faster color printing is all you are after
Each is rated for up to 33 single-sided Letter ppm, and the scanning hardware has no effect on that rating.
- Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Similar
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Similar
In practice
Differences you will notice
Dropping the scanner saves height but leaves the printer’s footprint the same
With a printer under an open shelf, HL-L8430CDW takes 4.8 inches off the closed-body height of MFC-L8730CDW. Width and depth stay the same, though. If you already own a scanner, it is a sensible way to avoid doubling up on a lid and a feeder. If your separate scanner takes up another part of the desk, the MFC may shrink the combined equipment footprint instead. Measure both complete setups.
How we worked this out
Both bodies measure 15.9 by 18.6 inches. The height difference is 18.1 - 13.3 = 4.8 inches. Since the area of any existing separate scanner is unknown, no net saving in desktop space is claimed.
The model without a scanner can take more print paper
For a team that switches among plain paper, letterhead and another approved stock, extra drawers may count for more than a built-in scanner. HL-L8430CDW handles up to 1,340 total input sheets with optional trays, whereas MFC-L8730CDW tops out at 800. That can make the print-only model the better choice to expand. The standard 150-sheet output bin stays the same size on both, so for long runs someone still has to collect the pages.
How we worked this out
The optional input totals are 540 sheets apart. In their standard configurations both hold 300 input and 150 output sheets at the stated paper weight. Added trays cost extra and call for more installation height.
A scanner upgrade ought to eliminate a genuine handoff
Say you regularly sign forms, scan both sides and copy pages from a book. The MFC does all three in the same place, while with HL-L8430CDW you go back to a separate capture device for the first two kinds of original. If your documents come in digitally and the occasional signature is dealt with elsewhere, though, both printers print at the same rated pace. Go with the HL unless the MFC would take away a recurring handoff that bothers you.
How we worked this out
HL only prints. MFC adds a Letter glass and an 80-sheet duplex feeder to the same 33-ppm rated print engine. Nothing here claims faster file transfer or better scan quality.
Option A
Brother, HL-L8430CDW
HL-L8430CDW
A body 4.8 inches lower is yours when a separate scanner already does the job.
- Best for
- A body 4.8 inches lower is yours when a separate scanner already does the job.
Facts we checked
- Desk footprint: Print only. Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 13.3 inches and weight 45.9 lb.
- Paper expansion: 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray, 150-sheet output. Optional total input up to 1,340 sheets.
- Scanning and copying: Print-only model with no scanner.
- Color printing pace: Up to 33 single-sided Letter ppm, black or color.
Option B
Brother, MFC-L8730CDW
MFC-L8730CDW
An 80-sheet one-pass duplex feeder can take the place of a separate document scanner, within its paper limits.
- Best for
- An 80-sheet one-pass duplex feeder can take the place of a separate document scanner, within its paper limits.
Facts we checked
- Desk footprint: Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 18.1 inches, width x depth x height. Weight 56.5 lb.
- Paper expansion: 300-sheet standard input, 150-sheet output. Optional total input up to 800 sheets.
- Scanning and copying: 80-sheet single-pass duplex feeder, based on 20 lb paper. Letter-size document glass.
- Color printing pace: Up to 33 single-sided Letter ppm, black or color.
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Brother HL-L8430CDW | Brother MFC-L8730CDW | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Desk footprint | Print only. Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 13.3 inches and weight 45.9 lb. | Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 18.1 inches, width x depth x height. Weight 56.5 lb. | Going print-only frees up height, but the base is no narrower or shallower. |
| Paper expansion | 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray, 150-sheet output. Optional total input up to 1,340 sheets. | 300-sheet standard input, 150-sheet output. Optional total input up to 800 sheets. | Compare the full configuration you plan to buy, rather than a photo that shows optional trays. |
| Scanning and copying | Print-only model with no scanner. | 80-sheet single-pass duplex feeder, based on 20 lb paper. Letter-size document glass. | Only if its glass and feeder handle your originals can the MFC replace a separate scanner. |
| Color printing pace | Up to 33 single-sided Letter ppm, black or color. | Up to 33 single-sided Letter ppm, black or color. | A higher rated print speed is not a reason to buy the all-in-one. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Brother HL-L8430CDW
- Reaching the maximum input takes optional lower trays, which add height. Standard input is just 300 sheets.
With Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Not every original works on Letter-size glass. Oversize or unsuitable documents may still call for a different way of capturing them.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
You already have scanning covered, or more paper drawers are the upgrade you want most
Go with Brother HL-L8430CDW. HL stands lower and documents the larger optional input.
A built-in flatbed and duplex ADF take out a routine step that needs a separate device
Go with Brother MFC-L8730CDW. The MFC handles those jobs within the same printer footprint.
More than 150 printed sheets need to pile up before anyone collects them
Neither model fits. Added input trays leave the documented output capacity as it was.
Decision guide
Before you buy
Less equipment on the desk is the goal, yet folding a scanner into the printer may duplicate hardware and cut into the paper expansion you really need.
What this page can’t tell you
- Without current complete-package prices, there is no total-cost ranking.
- A missing cartridge listing is not taken as proof of incompatibility.
- Maximum paper input and rated ppm alike fail to prove unattended reliability.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the laser printers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brother HL-L8430CDW |
|
| |
| Brother MFC-L8730CDW |
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Brother HL-L8430CDW
A body 4.8 inches lower is yours when a separate scanner already does the job.
Input can grow to a documented 1,340 sheets with trays bought separately.
See price & reviews on AmazonBrother MFC-L8730CDW
An 80-sheet one-pass duplex feeder can take the place of a separate document scanner, within its paper limits.
Eligible book pages get copied on the flatbed, with room for the lid to open.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money