The catch
Brother MFC-L8730CDW
The main tray handles up to 28 lb bond and no more. A larger feeder does not make it the better choice for every kind of paper.
Side by side
Brother MFC-L8730CDW vs Canon MF753Cdw II: Canon’s main tray accepts heavier paper, and Brother needs fewer scan reloads
Quick verdict
The MFC-L8730CDW suits eligible 51- to 80-sheet scan packets and routine printing above 4,000 pages a month, within its 5,000-page recommendation. The MF753Cdw II is the better pick when your packets fit 50 sheets and approved heavier paper has to stay in the main tray. Canon accepts up to 200 gsm there, whereas Brother lists 28 lb bond, about 105 gsm. A closed-body measurement for neither is enough to approve a shelf installation.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
Fewer trips to the machine matter more than how many sides get scanned
Say the office printer is across the room and a typical signed packet runs to 70 sheets. Brother takes the eligible packet in a single load, while Canon needs a second load once the first 50 are through. For someone who alternates paperwork with phone calls, that is a real difference in interruptions, even though both machines scan both sides automatically. With 20-sheet packets the bigger feeder saves no loading step at all.
Where this comes from
With 70 supported sheets, ceiling(70/80) = 1 versus ceiling(70/50) = 2. This counts loads only. It does not count minutes, processing time or error rates.
The catch
Canon MF753Cdw II
You have to split any packet over 50 eligible sheets. The Amazon offer selected came from Provantage LLC, so look at the seller and warranty terms.
Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Why pick it
- Eligible 51- to 80-sheet scan packets go in without being split.
- A routine workload of more than 4,000 and up to 5,000 printed pages a month is covered.
- The catch
- The main tray handles up to 28 lb bond and no more. A larger feeder does not make it the better choice for every kind of paper.
Canon MF753Cdw II
- Why pick it
- Approved heavier media, up to 200 gsm, can stay in the main paper tray.
- Take the lower body if ordinary packets already fit the 50-sheet feeder, once you have checked lid clearance.
- The catch
- You have to split any packet over 50 eligible sheets. The Amazon offer selected came from Provantage LLC, so look at the seller and warranty terms.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
Larger scan packets, heavier main-tray paper and shared-office placement are what to weigh. Pick the color all-in-one that suits your paperwork, using the exact Amazon models.
Both are current color laser all-in-ones that come with fax, wired networking and one-pass duplex scanning. The reasonable trade-off for a buyer is Brother’s larger feeder against Canon’s paper flexibility and lower body.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
One packet holds seventy eligible original sheets to scan
Brother takes them in one ADF load, where Canon needs two.
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Better fit
- Canon MF753Cdw II
- Caution
Approved 160 gsm handouts need to remain in the main tray
Brother’s main tray tops out below that weight, while Canon’s published range includes it. Check the media type as well.
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Not suitable
- Canon MF753Cdw II
- Better fit
Your team regularly prints 4,500 pages a month
Brother’s recommendation goes up to 5,000, Canon’s to 4,000.
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Better fit
- Canon MF753Cdw II
- Caution
An enclosed shelf allows only the closed dimensions
Before buying either, check how the scanner opens, plus airflow and tray access.
- Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Caution
- Canon MF753Cdw II
- Caution
In practice
Differences you will notice
Fewer trips to the machine matter more than how many sides get scanned
Say the office printer is across the room and a typical signed packet runs to 70 sheets. Brother takes the eligible packet in a single load, while Canon needs a second load once the first 50 are through. For someone who alternates paperwork with phone calls, that is a real difference in interruptions, even though both machines scan both sides automatically. With 20-sheet packets the bigger feeder saves no loading step at all.
How we worked this out
With 70 supported sheets, ceiling(70/80) = 1 versus ceiling(70/50) = 2. This counts loads only. It does not count minutes, processing time or error rates.
Thicker handouts determine which tray you have left free
A small business that regularly uses heavier sheets and only occasionally prints on letterhead gets more from Canon. It can keep more approved paper weights in the main drawer and save the multipurpose tray for the occasional job. On Brother, main-tray stock tops out around 105 gsm. The multipurpose path extends that range, but it is then tied up. If all you print is ordinary 20 lb paper, this advantage mostly vanishes.
How we worked this out
Brother’s main tray takes 16-28 lb bond, roughly 60-105 gsm. According to the Canon brochure, approved main-tray media run 60-200 gsm. Weight is not enough to approve a coating, label or custom sheet.
A rush now and then and a sustained workload call for different purchases
When several people together print 4,500 pages every month, Brother stays inside its recommended range and Canon goes over its 4,000-page upper recommendation. That is a better reason to lean toward Brother than its feeder is, if everyone scans short packets. If 4,500 pages was just one unusual month, look at your usual workload first and do not treat a single rush as a lasting need.
How we worked this out
4,500 sits under Brother’s recommended monthly maximum of 5,000 and over Canon’s of 4,000. Maximum duty cycle is left out. Nothing here predicts failure or operating cost.
Option A
Brother, MFC-L8730CDW
MFC-L8730CDW
Eligible 51- to 80-sheet scan packets go in without being split.
- Best for
- Eligible 51- to 80-sheet scan packets go in without being split.
Facts we checked
- Originals per feeder load: 80-sheet single-pass duplex feeder, based on 20 lb paper. Letter-size document glass.
- The paper kept in the main tray: 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray. Main tray accepts 16-28 lb bond, multipurpose 16-43 lb.
- Routine monthly printing: Recommended up to 5,000 pages monthly.
- Body height and access: Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 18.1 inches, width x depth x height. Weight 56.5 lb.
Option B
Canon, MF753Cdw II
MF753Cdw II
Approved heavier media, up to 200 gsm, can stay in the main paper tray.
- Best for
- Approved heavier media, up to 200 gsm, can stay in the main paper tray.
Facts we checked
- Originals per feeder load: MF753Cdw II has a 50-sheet one-pass duplex ADF. The MF751Cdw II is different and scans one side through its feeder.
- The paper kept in the main tray: 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray. Approved main-tray media spans 60-200 gsm.
- Routine monthly printing: Recommended 750 to 4,000 pages monthly.
- Body height and access: Body height 17 inches. The manual requires at least 4 inches around the machine and lists a larger maximum operating envelope.
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Brother MFC-L8730CDW | Canon MF753Cdw II | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Originals per feeder load | 80-sheet single-pass duplex feeder, based on 20 lb paper. Letter-size document glass. | MF753Cdw II has a 50-sheet one-pass duplex ADF. The MF751Cdw II is different and scans one side through its feeder. | Brother cuts the loading trips for a particular packet size. Both already automate the second side. |
| The paper kept in the main tray | 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray. Main tray accepts 16-28 lb bond, multipurpose 16-43 lb. | 250-sheet main tray plus 50-sheet multipurpose tray. Approved main-tray media spans 60-200 gsm. | On Canon you can run approved stock that Brother would force into a different path or that lies outside Brother’s stated range. |
| Routine monthly printing | Recommended up to 5,000 pages monthly. | Recommended 750 to 4,000 pages monthly. | Once the workload passes 4,000, the choice changes, even if both printers look fast enough for one job. |
| Body height and access | Closed body 15.9 x 18.6 x 18.1 inches, width x depth x height. Weight 56.5 lb. | Body height 17 inches. The manual requires at least 4 inches around the machine and lists a larger maximum operating envelope. | A lower closed body helps only when the scanner can still open once installed. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Brother MFC-L8730CDW
- Supported loose originals are what the 80-sheet ADF is for. Books still go on the Letter glass, which needs open space above it.
With Canon MF753Cdw II
- Canon needs a minimum of 4 inches around the machine. Extra paper capacity is an added cost too and makes it taller.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
Packets regularly run past 50 sheets, or routine printing goes beyond 4,000 pages a month
Go with Brother MFC-L8730CDW. Those particular demands are met by the larger feeder and the higher recommended workload.
Packets are shorter and approved heavy paper has to go in the main tray
Go with Canon MF753Cdw II. Canon’s paper handling lets you keep the alternate tray free for another stock.
The required working and ventilation clearances are not something you can provide
Neither model fits. Sort out the installation first, then choose a printer.
Decision guide
Before you buy
Scanning paperwork in fewer trips to the machine is what you need, and the same printer also has to handle heavier handouts and sit among other office equipment.
What this page can’t tell you
- The Canon brochure and manual give different output capacities, so this page does not rest on that figure.
- There was no matched test of speed, image quality or consumable cost.
- Network and cloud destinations take their own setup on both products.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the laser printers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brother MFC-L8730CDW |
|
| |
| Canon MF753Cdw II |
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Brother MFC-L8730CDW
Eligible 51- to 80-sheet scan packets go in without being split.
A routine workload of more than 4,000 and up to 5,000 printed pages a month is covered.
See price & reviews on AmazonCanon MF753Cdw II
Approved heavier media, up to 200 gsm, can stay in the main paper tray.
Take the lower body if ordinary packets already fit the 50-sheet feeder, once you have checked lid clearance.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money