The catch
Brother MFC-L5710DW
Its published ADF paper-weight range is narrower, and the taller body needs room above the scanner to open.
Side by side
Brother MFC-L5710DW vs Canon MF465dw II: Thinner originals feed through Canon, while Brother suits more monthly printing
Quick verdict
A sustained workload above 4,000 and up to 5,000 printed pages a month, within its recommendation, points to the MFC-L5710DW. The MF465dw II is the choice when approved thinner originals or a lower closed body are the tougher constraint. Canon accepts 13-28 lb bond originals through its feeder, against a range of 17-24 lb in the Brother brochure. Each holds 50 original sheets, and neither has a legal-length glass.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
Thin forms can flip the choice of the faster printer
Say your office does a lot of printing but also gets thin application forms. Look at the originals before the print engine. The Canon feeder covers originals in 13- to 16-pound bond, below the Brother brochure minimum of 17 lb, so eligible forms can stay in the automated workflow and off the glass. Paper that is torn, creased or otherwise unsuitable still calls for the proper manual procedure, whatever its weight.
Where this comes from
Canon ADF range: 13-28 lb bond. Brother ADF range in the US brochure: 17-24 lb. The part only Canon covers is 13 to below 17 lb. Condition, dimensions and coating are separate requirements.
The catch
Canon MF465dw II
It is recommended for up to 4,000 pages a month. Even with the lower closed body, you still need at least 4 inches around it plus room for parts that open.
Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Why pick it
- Sustained 4,001- to 5,000-page months stay within the published recommended maximum.
- A 100-sheet multipurpose print tray is available while plain paper stays in the main drawer.
- The catch
- Its published ADF paper-weight range is narrower, and the taller body needs room above the scanner to open.
Canon MF465dw II
- Why pick it
- Approved 13- to 16-pound bond originals, which fall below the Brother brochure range, can be fed. Condition and size need checking as well.
- The body is nearly 3 inches lower, as long as you still keep the required lid and ventilation clearance.
- The catch
- It is recommended for up to 4,000 pages a month. Even with the lower closed body, you still need at least 4 inches around it plus room for parts that open.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
Let monthly printing, thinner scan originals and working clearance guide you. Each feeds 50 sheets, and the differences that matter go beyond a printing-speed headline.
Both are current monochrome business all-in-ones offering fax, duplex scanning and 350-sheet print input. For a home office that splits its time between printing and capturing documents, they are close alternatives.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
Approved loose originals come in 15 lb bond
That is under the feeder minimum in the Brother brochure and inside the Canon range. Check every other restriction on originals.
- Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Not suitable
- Canon MF465dw II
- Better fit
You routinely print 4,500 pages a month
Brother recommends up to 5,000, Canon up to 4,000.
- Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Better fit
- Canon MF465dw II
- Caution
Sixty-sheet packets have to be loaded together
The document feeder on each takes 50 sheets.
- Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Not suitable
- Canon MF465dw II
- Not suitable
Ordinary print volume and a lower scanner body take priority
The Canon body sits lower, but the working space it requires still has to be there.
- Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Depends
- Canon MF465dw II
- Better fit
In practice
Differences you will notice
Thin forms can flip the choice of the faster printer
Say your office does a lot of printing but also gets thin application forms. Look at the originals before the print engine. The Canon feeder covers originals in 13- to 16-pound bond, below the Brother brochure minimum of 17 lb, so eligible forms can stay in the automated workflow and off the glass. Paper that is torn, creased or otherwise unsuitable still calls for the proper manual procedure, whatever its weight.
How we worked this out
Canon ADF range: 13-28 lb bond. Brother ADF range in the US brochure: 17-24 lb. The part only Canon covers is 13 to below 17 lb. Condition, dimensions and coating are separate requirements.
A claim of faster scanning will not solve repeated feeder loading
With short packets, Canon’s higher stated scan rate is worth a closer look at its workflow, particularly if scanning fills most of your day. If what bothers you is splitting a 60-sheet packet while you take calls, though, both machines have the same 50-sheet feeder and neither spares you that interruption. Look for a larger feeder. A faster scanner will not fix a capacity problem.
How we worked this out
Each ADF takes 50 supported sheets, so ceiling(60/50) = 2 loads on either. Canon runs up to 100/80 duplex ipm at 300x300 and Brother up to 60/42 under stated ISO conditions. Because processing settings differ, no timed end-to-end result is drawn from them.
Pick the part of your workload that is really growing
Suppose two people now print 4,500 pages every month. Brother’s recommended ceiling of 5,000 pages fits that pattern and Canon’s 4,000-page recommendation does not. If printing stays well below 4,000 and what you mainly need is more usable space above the scanner, Canon’s lower body may be worth more to you. Its manual still calls for working clearance, so a shelf that only just fits the closed printer does not settle the installation.
How we worked this out
4,500 falls between the published recommended maxima. The body heights of 17.6 and 14.75 differ by 2.85 inches, nearly 3 inches. Clearance is a separate matter from body height.
Option A
Brother, MFC-L5710DW
MFC-L5710DW
Sustained 4,001- to 5,000-page months stay within the published recommended maximum.
- Best for
- Sustained 4,001- to 5,000-page months stay within the published recommended maximum.
Facts we checked
- Originals the feeder accepts: Brochure ADF range 17-24 lb bond, 50-sheet capacity at 20 lb.
- Scan rate versus stack size: 50-sheet one-pass duplex ADF. Rated duplex scan speed up to 60 black or 42 color images per minute, with advanced features off.
- Closed body and working space: Closed body 16.4 x 18.1 x 17.6 inches. Standard paper input 350 sheets and output 150.
- Recurring printed workload: Recommended monthly maximum 5,000 pages, up to 48 simplex Letter ppm.
Option B
Canon, MF465dw II
MF465dw II
Approved 13- to 16-pound bond originals, which fall below the Brother brochure range, can be fed. Condition and size need checking as well.
- Best for
- Approved 13- to 16-pound bond originals, which fall below the Brother brochure range, can be fed. Condition and size need checking as well.
Facts we checked
- Originals the feeder accepts: 50-sheet automatic two-sided ADF. Originals may be 13-28 lb bond. Duplex scanning is rated up to 100 black or 80 color images per minute at 300 x 300 dpi.
- Scan rate versus stack size: 50-sheet automatic two-sided ADF. Originals may be 13-28 lb bond. Duplex scanning is rated up to 100 black or 80 color images per minute at 300 x 300 dpi.
- Closed body and working space: Closed body 16.5 x 18.125 x 14.75 inches in the US manual. Leave at least 4 inches around the machine and room for opened parts.
- Recurring printed workload: Recommended monthly maximum 4,000 pages, up to 42 simplex Letter ppm.
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Brother MFC-L5710DW | Canon MF465dw II | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Originals the feeder accepts | Brochure ADF range 17-24 lb bond, 50-sheet capacity at 20 lb. | 50-sheet automatic two-sided ADF. Originals may be 13-28 lb bond. Duplex scanning is rated up to 100 black or 80 color images per minute at 300 x 300 dpi. | Look at your thin originals before you pick a printer. Feeder capacity says nothing about whether a given material is compatible. |
| Scan rate versus stack size | 50-sheet one-pass duplex ADF. Rated duplex scan speed up to 60 black or 42 color images per minute, with advanced features off. | 50-sheet automatic two-sided ADF. Originals may be 13-28 lb bond. Duplex scanning is rated up to 100 black or 80 color images per minute at 300 x 300 dpi. | Each holds 50 sheets. Canon quotes the higher scan rate, yet a 60-sheet packet still needs a reload. |
| Closed body and working space | Closed body 16.4 x 18.1 x 17.6 inches. Standard paper input 350 sheets and output 150. | Closed body 16.5 x 18.125 x 14.75 inches in the US manual. Leave at least 4 inches around the machine and room for opened parts. | Canon sits lower, though its opening and clearance rules still decide how it can be installed. |
| Recurring printed workload | Recommended monthly maximum 5,000 pages, up to 48 simplex Letter ppm. | Recommended monthly maximum 4,000 pages, up to 42 simplex Letter ppm. | Brother can come out ahead on sustained printing even when Canon has the better scan workflow. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Brother MFC-L5710DW
- Once heavy stock goes above 28 lb bond, printing switches to the half-speed, straight-output procedure, and that makes rear access matter.
With Canon MF465dw II
- Keep MF465dw II, US item 7188C006, separate from the earlier model, and do not assume every software workflow reaches its maximum scan rate.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
Sustained print volume tops 4,000 a month and your originals meet the Brother feeder rules
Go with Brother MFC-L5710DW. The 5710 has the higher recommended print workload.
The setup depends on eligible thinner originals or the lower body
Go with Canon MF465dw II. Canon handles those particular constraints, as long as you stay within its workload and clearance limits.
The real problem is that more than 50 originals have to be loaded at once
Neither model fits. Get a larger ADF and do not mistake scan speed for capacity.
Decision guide
Before you buy
Your printing volume calls for a business machine, yet the originals you receive and the space you scan in may count for more than print speed.
What this page can’t tell you
- Scan claims that differ do not add up to a matched file-completion benchmark.
- Canon body dimensions come from the exact manual and not from a mix of rounded retailer figures.
- Color printing and a legal-length glass are missing from both models.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the laser printers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Brother MFC-L5710DW |
|
| |
| Canon MF465dw II |
|
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Brother MFC-L5710DW
Sustained 4,001- to 5,000-page months stay within the published recommended maximum.
A 100-sheet multipurpose print tray is available while plain paper stays in the main drawer.
See price & reviews on AmazonCanon MF465dw II
Approved 13- to 16-pound bond originals, which fall below the Brother brochure range, can be fed. Condition and size need checking as well.
The body is nearly 3 inches lower, as long as you still keep the required lid and ventilation clearance.
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money