The catch
Canon MF465dw II
The scanner picks up color originals, but it prints only in black and white.
Side by side
Canon MF465dw II vs Brother MFC-L5915DW: Brother handles larger stacks, Canon needs less space
Quick verdict
A smaller office with double-sided paperwork should take the MF465dw II. For larger scanning batches and heavier monthly monochrome printing, the MFC-L5915DW is the choice, as long as there is room for its bigger body.
Before you buy
Why, and what it costs you
Just one feeder has room for a sixty-page stack
The Canon 50-sheet feeder is exceeded by sixty suitable sheets, which fit within the Brother 70-sheet limit. That spares you from splitting the stack into separate loads, and no particular scan-time advantage is claimed.
Where this comes from
60>50, 60<=70. ADF is single pass on both.
The catch
Brother MFC-L5915DW
It cannot print in color, and it is far bigger than home-office models.
Canon MF465dw II
- Why pick it
- You keep to 4000 pages a month or less
- You want a more compact multifunction machine
- The catch
- The scanner picks up color originals, but it prints only in black and white.
Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Why pick it
- Loose scans of more than 50 sheets are routine for you
- You print above 4000 pages in a month
- The catch
- It cannot print in color, and it is far bigger than home-office models.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money
What this page compares
Set 50-sheet and 70-sheet scan stacks, monthly printing limits and desk footprint side by side, then pick a monochrome workhorse that suits a typical month.
A smaller office with double-sided paperwork should take the MF465dw II. For larger scanning batches and heavier monthly monochrome printing, the MFC-L5915DW is the choice, as long as there is room for its bigger body.
Which one fits
Pick the situations that sound like you
Records packet, sixty-page and two-sided
The whole supported stack goes into the Brother feeder.
- Canon MF465dw II
- Caution
- Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Better fit
Each month, five thousand monochrome pages
This volume falls within Brother’s published recommendation.
- Canon MF465dw II
- Caution
- Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Better fit
A small office short on worktop surface
The closed footprint is smaller on the Canon.
- Canon MF465dw II
- Better fit
- Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Depends
Charts have to stay in color
Neither prints beyond black and white.
- Canon MF465dw II
- Not suitable
- Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Not suitable
In practice
Differences you will notice
Just one feeder has room for a sixty-page stack
The Canon 50-sheet feeder is exceeded by sixty suitable sheets, which fit within the Brother 70-sheet limit. That spares you from splitting the stack into separate loads, and no particular scan-time advantage is claimed.
How we worked this out
60>50, 60<=70. ADF is single pass on both.
About 21% more closed-body surface area is needed by the Brother
Width times depth comes to 300.46 square inches for Canon and 362.7 for Brother. That is about 21% more, not counting paper trays, lid movement and clearances.
How we worked this out
16.6 x 18.1=300.46.19.5 x 18.6=362.7. The difference is 20.7%.
A monthly volume of five thousand pages reshapes the shortlist
A recurring 5000-page workload goes past the Canon 4000-page recommended ceiling and stays within the Brother 8000-page recommendation. The far larger duty-cycle number is no license to ignore the difference.
How we worked this out
Recommended monthly maximum from the manufacturer: 4000 against 8000.
Option A
Canon, MF465dw II
MF465dw II
Monochrome office work at a busy pace, with regular scanning of two-sided paperwork.
- Best for
- You keep to 4000 pages a month or less
Facts we checked
- Document feeder: Single-pass duplex, 50-sheet
- Monthly printing recommended: 750 to 4000 pages
- Output on Letter: Up to 42 ppm
- Footprint when closed: 16.6 x 18.1 inches
Option B
Brother, MFC-L5915DW
MFC-L5915DW
Quick monochrome printing and scanning for an office that runs on documents.
- Best for
- Loose scans of more than 50 sheets are routine for you
Facts we checked
- Document feeder: Single-pass duplex, 70-sheet
- Monthly printing recommended: Up to 8000 pages
- Output on Letter: Up to 50 ppm
- Footprint when closed: 19.5 x 18.6 inches
Spec by spec
Where they really differ
| Spec | Canon MF465dw II | Brother MFC-L5915DW | In practice |
|---|---|---|---|
| Document feeder | 50-sheet single-pass duplex | 70-sheet single-pass duplex | A larger stack goes into the Brother in one load. |
| Recommended monthly printing | 750 to 4000 pages | Up to 8000 pages | For recurring workload, recommended volume is a better guide than duty cycle. |
| Letter output | Up to 42 ppm | Up to 50 ppm | The rated difference counts when print batches are long. |
| Closed footprint | 16.6 x 18.1 inches | 19.5 x 18.6 inches | More worktop area goes to the Brother. |
| Standard paper input | 350 sheets | 350 sheets | Base paper storage is not increased by higher throughput. |
Trade-offs
What each pick costs you
With Canon MF465dw II
- Feeder loads have to be separate for scan packets above 50 suitable sheets.
With Brother MFC-L5915DW
- With a base paper input of 350 sheets, loading a full 500-sheet ream at once takes extra trays.
Change of plan
When the answer changes
Printing every month goes beyond 4000 pages
Go with Brother MFC-L5915DW. Brother’s recommended workload is higher.
Moderate workload, and counter space is tight
Go with Canon MF465dw II. Two-sided scanning stays on the Canon, in a smaller body.
Printed output has to be in color
Neither model fits. You need a color laser-class model.
Decision guide
How to decide
The MF465dw II fits a smaller office handling double-sided paperwork. If you scan bigger batches and print more each month in monochrome, choose the MFC-L5915DW, provided its larger body fits your space.
Choose based on a typical month
For monthly volume, Canon recommends 750 to 4000 pages and Brother allows up to 8000. Those numbers describe a recurring workload. Maximum duty cycle is another engineering limit, and it does not turn the Canon into a sensible default for a 5000-page monthly routine.
Feeder capacity may outweigh print speed
One pass captures both sides on either machine. Brother takes 70 sheets where Canon takes 50, which helps when a real packet lands between the limits. A ten-page job gains nothing from the extra capacity.
Base configurations hold the same amount of paper
Standard input is 350 sheets on both. The Brother prints faster, yet it does not hold more paper unless you buy optional trays. Count those parts when you compare complete installations.
Leave room for originals and printed pages
Both the width and depth of the Brother are greater. Working clearance is not included in either closed footprint. Put the printer where people can load the ADF, raise the flatbed cover and pick up printouts without shifting the machine.
What this page can’t tell you
- Print speeds shown are manufacturer ratings, without matched hands-on testing behind them.
- Toner yields depend on standardized test documents and vary with content.
By the numbers
What the data shows
What we found across the laser printers we compare, plus the checked facts behind each finding.
Show the facts and the math
| Product | Needs it meets | Facts we checked | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|
| Canon MF465dw II |
|
| |
| Brother MFC-L5915DW |
|
|
Ready to buy
See today’s price and what owners say
Open either model on Amazon for the current price, customer reviews and delivery options.
Canon MF465dw II
You keep to 4000 pages a month or less
See price & reviews on AmazonBrother MFC-L5915DW
Loose scans of more than 50 sheets are routine for you
See price & reviews on AmazonEach link opens in a new tab.
We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money