Best roof cargo boxes for the way you use them

For family luggage and seasonal gear on a typical raised-crossbar setup, Thule Motion 3 XL is the place to begin. Yakima SkyBox NX XL is the better pick when long skis, a short roof or tight hatch clearance limits which shell will physically fit. The matcher below screens out the hard requirements first.

Quick picks

We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases. How we make money

roof cargo box finder

What do you need from a roof cargo box?

Tap as many as apply. The list re-sorts as you go.

Match the box to bars, hatch and longest gearEnter my measurements

Take the measurements from your actual vehicle. Before showing a fit, the tool screens volume, ski length, bar spread and front clearance.

2 models fit your answers2 boxes pass every measurement

This checks 16 cu ft, a 28-inch bar spread, 52 inches before the hatch and your longest gear.

For Thule, measure from the center of the front crossbar to where the roof meets the hatch. Do not measure to the tip of the open hatch. This narrows the list but does not replace the maker's vehicle fit guide. Only boxes with published bar-spread and hatch-clearance figures can pass. Confirm crossbar type, load limits, mounting clearance and antenna clearance before you buy.

Position 2
Thule Force 3 XL

Thule, Force 3 XL

Thule Force 3 XL

This box has 18 cubic feet of space and takes gear up to 200 centimeters long.

Best forbring skis without folding down the seats, and pack for a family of four

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 200 centimeters long fits.
  • Documented crossbar spread is 21.875 to 36.625 inches.

What you give up

  • This version comes in black matte. If you want a glossy shell, go with Motion instead.
  • Per the US fit chart, front bar to hatch must measure more than 53 1/16 inches.
Position 3
Thule Motion 3 XXL

Thule, Motion 3 XXL Black Glossy

Thule Motion 3 XXL

You get 21 cubic feet of space, with room for gear up to 215 centimeters long.

Best fortransport skis with the seats left up and pack for a family of four

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 21 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 215 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Among the longest and widest boxes listed here, it calls for exact checks of hatch clearance and roof length.
  • With a low roof rating, the empty box alone takes up a sizable share of the load allowance.
Position 4
Thule Force 3 L

Thule, Force 3 L

Thule Force 3 L

It offers 16 cubic feet and fits gear up to 175 centimeters in length.

Best fortake skis along with the seats left up and suit a shorter roof

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 16 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 175 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Skis from 180 to 200 cm are too long for it.
  • At 16.8 inches above the crossbar, it is not built for low garages.
Position 5
Thule Pulse 2 L

Thule, Pulse 2 L

Thule Pulse 2 L

Inside you get 16 cubic feet, and the length limit for gear is 175 centimeters.

Best forcarry skis with the seats left up and stay clear of the rear hatch

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 16 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 175 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Many adult skis are longer than its 175 cm ski limit.
  • Its central locking is more basic than the SlideLock feedback system on the Motion.
Position 6
Yakima SkyBox NX LG

Yakima, SkyBox NX 16 LG

Yakima SkyBox NX LG

Volume is 16 cubic feet, and it takes gear up to 175 centimeters long.

Best forcarry skis while the seats stay up, and keep clear of the rear hatch

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 16 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 175 centimeters long fits.
  • The documented crossbar spread runs from 24 to 36 inches.

What you give up

  • Skis of 180 to 200 cm will not go in.
  • Lifting the 47-pound shell on or off by yourself can be awkward.
Position 7
Yakima SkyBox NX XL

Yakima, SkyBox NX 18 XL

Yakima SkyBox NX XL

You can fit gear up to 195 centimeters long in its 18 cubic feet.

Best forkeep the seats up while carrying skis, and pack for a family of four

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18 cubic feet.
  • It accepts gear up to 195 centimeters long.
  • The documented crossbar spread runs from 24 to 40 inches.

What you give up

  • 200 cm Nordic skis are a little longer than its 195 cm ski limit.
  • Empty, it weighs 53 pounds, so watch low-rated roofs and removing it solo.
Position 8
SportRack Vista XL

SportRack, Vista XL SR7018

SportRack Vista XL

It has 18 cubic feet of space and opens at the rear.

Best forfit a shorter roof and pack for a family of four

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18 cubic feet.
  • The box uses rear opening access.
  • Its published exterior size is 63 x 38 x 19 inches.

What you give up

  • The rear opening can be awkward on a tall SUV, and you cannot load from both sides.
  • The 63-inch shell is short, so think luggage rather than long skis.
Position 9
Thule Motion 3 XXL Low

Thule, Motion 3 XXL Low Black Glossy

Thule Motion 3 XXL Low

It holds 18 cubic feet and accepts gear as long as 215 centimeters.

Best forleave the seats up for skis and keep the rear hatch clear

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 215 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Although it is low, the shell is long and still needs plenty of hatch clearance.
  • With just 13 inches of interior height, tall luggage does not suit it.
Position 10
Thule Motion 3 L

Thule, Motion 3 L Titan Glossy

Thule Motion 3 L

Its 16 cubic feet can take gear up to 180 centimeters long.

Best formove skis with the seats left up while keeping the rear hatch clear

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 16 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 180 centimeters long fits inside.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Skis of 200 cm do not fit.
  • For a trip with four people, 16 cubic feet leaves less slack than the XL or XXL does.
Position 11
Thule Force 3 M

Thule, Force 3 M

Thule Force 3 M

It holds 14 cubic feet, and the longest gear it accepts is 155 centimeters.

Best forsuit a shorter roof and stay clear of the rear hatch

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 14 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 155 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Most adult skis are longer than its 155 cm limit.
  • With its tall 17.4-inch profile, it adds more garage height than low-profile boxes do.
Position 12
Thule Pulse 2 M

Thule, Pulse 2 M

Thule Pulse 2 M

This box offers 14 cubic feet, and gear can be up to 155 centimeters long.

Best forfit a shorter roof and leave the rear hatch free

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 14 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 155 centimeters long fits.
  • Dualside access is how it opens.

What you give up

  • Ordinary adult skis longer than 155 cm will not fit.
  • Fourteen cubic feet goes fast once four travelers pack their luggage.
Position 13
JEGS 18 Cubic Foot Rooftop Cargo Carrier

JEGS, 555-90098

JEGS 18 Cubic Foot Rooftop Cargo Carrier

The documented crossbar spread is 24 to 35 inches, and the box has 18 cubic feet of space.

Best forhandle a family of four's packing on a shorter roof

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18 cubic feet.
  • The documented crossbar spread runs from 24 to 35 inches.
  • It opens from both sides.

What you give up

  • Its wide, short shape suits luggage and camping gear, and skis are out.
  • On certain vehicles you have to drill new mounting holes, strictly as the instructions permit.
Position 14
INNO Wedge 660 Black

INNO, BRM660BK

INNO Wedge 660 Black

It offers 11 cubic feet and opens from both sides.

Best forcarry skis with the seats up and clear a low garage

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 11 cubic feet.
  • It opens from both sides.
  • Published exterior dimensions are 80 x 33 x 11 inches.

What you give up

  • Ordinary suitcases will not fit with only 8.25 inches of internal height.
  • Family packing calls for more room than Eleven cubic feet, which fits a specialized ski and low-profile load.
Position 15
SportRack Horizon L

SportRack, Horizon L SR7016

SportRack Horizon L

SportRack lists skis up to 178 centimeters long, and the box offers 16 cubic feet.

Best forkeep the seats up when carrying skis and suit a shorter roof

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 16 cubic feet.
  • Skis up to 178 centimeters long are listed in the US manufacturer specification.
  • It opens on the passenger side.

What you give up

  • It opens only on the passenger side, which is a hassle in a garage or tight parking space.
  • Skis longer than the published 178 cm allowance need a different box.
Position 16
SportRack Horizon Alpine

SportRack, Horizon Alpine SR7011

SportRack Horizon Alpine

Gear up to 210 centimeters long fits in its 11 cubic feet.

Best forcarry skis with the seats up and stay under a light roof-load limit

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 11 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 210 centimeters long fits.
  • It opens on the passenger side.

What you give up

  • Its narrow 11-cubic-foot interior rules it out as a family luggage box.
  • Loading only from the passenger side is less flexible than opening on both sides.
Position 17
INNO Ridge Cargo Box

INNO, BRA240BK

INNO Ridge Cargo Box

It holds 8 cubic feet and opens on the passenger side.

Best forsuit a shorter roof and stay under a light roof-load limit

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 8 cubic feet.
  • It opens on the passenger side.
  • Published exterior dimensions are 55.1 x 27.6 x 13.4 inches.

What you give up

  • For a family's packing list, eight cubic feet is too little.
  • Integrated clamps with dual-side access are handier than the passenger-side-only opening and U-bolt hardware here.
Position 18
Rhino-Rack MasterFit 440L

Rhino-Rack, RMFT440

Rhino-Rack MasterFit 440L

Gear up to 180 centimeters long goes into its 15.5 cubic feet.

Best forcarry skis with the seats up and fit a shorter roof

Why it suits you

  • The box holds 15.5 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 180 centimeters long fits inside.
  • The documented crossbar spread runs from 24.4 to 36.6 inches.

What you give up

  • At 38.6 pounds, it takes more effort to get onto the roof than a lighter box would.
  • The separate RUBK-MF fitting kit is required with some heavy-duty bar systems.
Position 19
Rhino-Rack MasterFit 530L

Rhino-Rack, RMFT530A

Rhino-Rack MasterFit 530L

You get 18.7 cubic feet, with space for gear up to 210.8 centimeters long.

Best forstow skis with the seats up while packing for a family of four

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 18.7 cubic feet.
  • Gear up to 210.8 centimeters long fits.
  • Documented crossbar spread is 21.7 to 39.4 inches.

What you give up

  • With an 85-inch shell, hatch and roof length both need careful checking.
  • On a roof with a light rating, its 47.4-pound empty weight cuts into the cargo allowance.
Position 20
Yakima DeepSpace 10 Cargo Box

Yakima, 8001171

DeepSpace 10 Cargo Box

Its documented crossbar spread is 32 to 46 inches, and capacity is 10 cubic feet.

Best forwork with widely spaced bars and leave space for a bike rack

Why it suits you

  • Capacity is 10 cubic feet.
  • Documented crossbar spread is 32 to 46 inches.
  • Wide-angle opening is how you get in.

What you give up

  • The 60-inch shell is too short for long skis, and ten cubic feet is a modest amount for a family.
  • It cannot mount to Yakima's EXO hitch system, and it requires a 32 to 46 inch crossbar spread.
Position 21
Thule Force 3 L Sport

Thule, 645650

Force 3 L Sport

Built for smaller loads that share the roof with other gear, this narrow box uses the Force 3 mounting and locking hardware.

Best forLeaving space on the crossbars for a bike carrier

Why it suits you

  • Advertised volume of 11 cubic feet
  • Published maximum ski length of 175 cm
  • Measures 75.2 by 24.7 by 16.7 inches outside

What you give up

  • Longer touring and Nordic skis exceed its 175 cm ski limit.
  • With a 20.2-inch interior that is narrow, wide suitcases fit poorly.
Position 22
Thule Force 3 XXL

Thule, 645950

Force 3 XXL

The biggest Force 3 offers 21 cubic feet and a 215 cm ski allowance, at the cost of a long, heavy shell.

Best forCarrying long skis and bulky family luggage, provided the vehicle passes the fit guide

Why it suits you

  • Advertised volume of 21 cubic feet
  • Published maximum ski length of 215 cm
  • Measures 91.4 by 35.2 by 17.9 inches outside

What you give up

  • Hatch clearance and roof length both need careful checking with a 91.4-inch shell.
  • Because the official installed-height field contradicts the overall dimensions, measure garage clearance directly.
Position 23
Thule Motion 3 XL Low

Thule, 639450 Black Glossy

Thule Motion 3 XL Low

This 14 cu ft box opens on both sides and takes skis up to 200 cm. It stands 12 inches above the crossbar by its published figure and has less internal height than the regular XL.

Best forHolding a long ski load closer to the crossbars

Why it suits you

  • Maximum ski length is 200 cm, with 14 cu ft of capacity.
  • Dual-side opening and PowerClick mounts.
  • Product page figure: 12 inches above the crossbar.

What you give up

  • Next to Motion 3 XL, the low shell loses packing height and four cubic feet.
  • The product page and the manual list different internal heights, so confirm the actual cargo clearance in the manual.
Position 24
Yakima SkyBox NX Skinny

Yakima, 8007368

Yakima SkyBox NX Skinny

This 12 cu ft box handles skis up to 195 cm. At 26.5 inches wide, it leaves more room beside it than the full-width SkyBox NX XL does.

Best forLong skis, with space left for another roof carrier

Why it suits you

  • Maximum ski length is 195 cm, with 12 cu ft of capacity.
  • Empty weight 43 lb, size 84 x 26.5 x 16 inches.
  • Crossbars 24 to 40 inches apart.

What you give up

  • Though overall length is the same 84 inches, it holds 12 cu ft against the 18 cu ft of the NX XL.
  • At 43 lb, it is heavy enough that the manual says to get help putting it on or taking it off the rack.
Position 25
Yakima SkyBox NX XXL

Yakima, 8007371

Yakima SkyBox NX XXL

This 22 cu ft box opens on both sides and takes skis up to 215 cm. Check its 60.5 lb shell and longer hatch-clearance requirement before you pack.

Best forLong skis and bulky family gear, on a roof that passes the load and hatch checks

Why it suits you

  • Maximum ski length is 215 cm, with 22 cu ft of capacity.
  • Empty weight 60.5 lb, size 90.5 x 36 x 19 inches.
  • Crossbars 24 to 40 inches apart.

What you give up

  • A big part of the roof-load allowance goes to the empty shell alone, at 60.5 lb.
  • By Yakima's method, hatch clearance must be 55 inches, which is five inches more than the NX XL needs.
Position 26
SportRack Sidekick

SportRack, SR7020

SportRack Sidekick

This 8 cu ft box opens on the passenger side and weighs 19.85 lb. Its manual warns of a 50 lb minimum load for higher-speed travel, so look at that restriction before you plan a light highway load.

Best forA compact load that satisfies the manual’s weight restriction for highway use

Why it suits you

  • Passenger-side opening and 8 cu ft of capacity.
  • Empty weight 19.85 lb, size 54 x 25 x 15.5 inches.
  • Cargo capacity is rated at 75 lb on the current product page.

What you give up

  • Above 40 mph, the manual advises against traveling empty and wants at least 50 lb in the carrier for higher-speed use.
  • Go by the stricter 75 lb cargo rating on the current page, and confirm the vehicle and rack limits too.

Buying advice

What to look for in a roof cargo box

These factors change which model suits you.

01

Start from the maker's fit guide

A box can be ruled out by roof shape, factory bars or clamp clearance, even if the basic measurements seem close enough.

02

Measure hatch clearance from the front bar

Take the distance from the middle of the front crossbar to where an open hatch would meet the box.

03

Cubic feet say nothing about shape

Equal cubic feet can still mean different gear fits, as with a short, tall box versus a long, low one.

04

The smallest load limit rules

The vehicle, crossbars and box each carry a load limit. Whichever published number is lowest sets the cap.

05

Long gear depends on interior length

A shell's outer length overstates how much room skis and boards get inside.

06

Opening on both sides earns its keep

On a wide vehicle, loading from the curb side, whichever it is, is easier and safer.

Guides

Narrow it down

Weigh two popular models against each other, or start from a shortlist built for one job.

Side-by-side comparisons

Thule Motion 3 XL vs Thule Force 3 XL, compared: Motion needs less hatch clearance, and both top out at 200 cm skisBefore you pick a box for family luggage or skis, weigh Motion 3 XL against Force 3 XL on hatch access, garage height and roof payload.Yakima SkyBox NX 16 LG vs Thule Motion 3 L compared: Motion handles 180 cm skis, while Yakima documents a 24–36-inch bar spreadA comparison of Yakima SkyBox NX 16 LG and Thule Motion 3 L on volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.Yakima SkyBox NX 18 XL vs Thule Force 3 XL compared: Thule takes 200 cm skis, while Yakima eases the hatch and wide-bar constraintsYakima SkyBox NX 18 XL set against Thule Force 3 XL on volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.INNO BRM660BK vs Thule Motion 3 XXL Low compared: INNO gives a lower profile, while Thule adds packing volume and fits 215 cm skisINNO BRM660BK against Thule Motion 3 XXL Low, judged on volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.SportRack Vista XL SR7018 vs JEGS 555-90098 compared: JEGS can be opened from either side, and Vista loads from the rearSportRack Vista XL SR7018 next to JEGS 555-90098, covering volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.Rhino-Rack RMFT440 vs Yakima SkyBox NX 16 LG compared: Rhino is lighter to carry, and Yakima documents hatch clearance and a flat floorRhino-Rack RMFT440 and Yakima SkyBox NX 16 LG, looked at through volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.Rhino-Rack RMFT530A vs Thule Motion 3 XXL compared: Thule fits 215 cm skis, while Rhino keeps a shorter shell and offers wider bar optionsRhino-Rack RMFT530A and Thule Motion 3 XXL, weighed on volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.INNO BRA240BK vs Thule Pulse 2 M compared: INNO makes short-roof lifting lighter, and Thule adds six cubic feet and dual accessINNO BRA240BK and Thule Pulse 2 M, set side by side on volume, gear length, vehicle measurements, loading and hardware.Thule Force 3 L vs L Sport: Sport has a narrower shell, leaving shared roof space without shortening ski fitSee how Force 3 L and L Sport differ in roof width, box weight and interior shape, and in how much luggage fits beside another roof-mounted carrier.Thule Force 3 XL vs XXL: Skis above 200 cm fit XXL, while XL has a shorter, lighter shellBefore you commit to the larger roof box, check Force 3 XL against XXL for long-ski fit, shell length, empty weight and usable luggage height.Thule Motion 3 XXL vs Force 3 XXL: Volume and ski limit are the same, but taller cases and wider cargo fit differentlyTwo 21-cubic-foot Thule XXL boxes, compared on internal dimensions, exterior width, weight and the luggage that has to fit under each lid.Thule Motion 3 XXL vs XXL Low: Low trims three inches above the bars while the ski allowance stays as longMotion 3 XXL against XXL Low, judged on internal luggage height, garage clearance, capacity and the almost identical effort of lifting either box.Force 3 L Sport vs Horizon Alpine: Horizon takes skis above 175 cm, and Thule opens on both sides in a shorter shellWhen another carrier shares the rack, how do Force 3 L Sport and SportRack Horizon Alpine compare on ski limits, roof width, empty weight and access?Thule Pulse 2 L vs Force 3 L: Pulse is lighter to lift, and Force adds SlideLock at the same volume and ski limitPulse 2 L and Force 3 L share a stated cargo volume. See how they differ in lifting weight, installed height, internal fit and lock operation.Thule Pulse 2 M vs Force 3 M: SlideLock costs Force six extra pounds, and both stop at 155 cm skisPulse 2 M and Force 3 M share a 14-cubic-foot capacity. See how they differ in handling weight, overhead height, usable interior and locking.Thule Pulse 2 M vs L: L fits skis above 155 cm, while M makes tight hatch-clearance planning easierPulse 2 M and L differ in luggage volume, ski length and shell weight, and gaining two extra cubic feet takes more roof length.Thule Force 3 M vs L: L gives more ski length, and M keeps a shorter shell with a taller interiorFor a compact car or a small family trip, Force 3 M and L differ in ski limits, roof length, empty weight and internal height.Thule Motion 3 L vs Force 3 L: Motion fits 176–180 cm skis, and Force takes up less roof widthMotion 3 L and Force 3 L both have 16-cubic-foot volume. See how they differ in ski limits, usable height, roof width and weight.Thule Pulse 2 L vs SkyBox NX 16: Pulse is lighter to lift, and SkyBox needs less roof length for its flat-floor layoutPulse 2 L and SkyBox NX LG share a 175 cm ski allowance. See how they differ in empty weight, exterior dimensions and mounting approach.Yakima SkyBox NX 16 vs 18: NX 18 takes skis above 175 cm, while NX 16 is more compact to park and storeSkyBox NX LG and XL differ in ski length, shell dimensions and weight, and the XL gives a family road trip two extra cubic feet.Thule Motion 3 XL vs SkyBox NX 18: Motion takes 196–200 cm skis, and Yakima keeps its body slightly shorterMotion 3 XL and SkyBox NX XL set side by side on their 200 and 195 cm ski limits, exterior proportions, mounting workflow and empty weight.Thule Force 3 L vs Force 3 XL: XL gives more ski length and volume, at the cost of a tighter hatch-clearance requirementForce 3 L and XL differ on 175 versus 200 cm skis, cargo volume, roof-load allowance and hatch clearance. Take your measurements before you size up.Thule Motion 3 L Titan vs Motion 3 XL Black compared: XL has more room for skis and luggage and adds no installed heightMotion 3 L Titan and XL Black differ in ski length, luggage volume, roof weight and hatch clearance, though both add the same stated height above the bars.Thule Force 3 L vs Yakima SkyBox NX 16 compared: Volume and ski limit match, and Thule fits narrower bar spacing and weighs lessForce 3 L and SkyBox NX 16 match on cargo volume and ski length. Check bar spread, body size, roof weight and each brand's hatch-fit method.Thule Force 3 L Sport vs Yakima SkyBox NX 16 compared: Sport leaves more roof width, and SkyBox adds volume at the same ski limitHow does the narrow Force 3 L Sport stack up against SkyBox NX 16 on shared roof space, ski length, cargo volume and load allowance? Verify rack and hatch fit.Thule Motion 3 XXL Low vs Yakima SkyBox NX 18 compared: Thule fits longer skis at a lower height, while Yakima shortens the shell for the same volumeTwo 18 cu ft boxes, weighed on 215 versus 195 cm skis, roof length, crossbar spread and hatch clearance. Check the low-profile claim against your own setup.Thule Motion 3 XL vs Motion 3 XXL Low compared: Both hold eighteen cubic feet, and XXL Low fits longer skis two inches lowerLong skis and garage clearance decide between Thule Motion 3 XL and XXL Low. See how equal cargo volume, roof-load costs, internal height and exact hatch-fit checks compare.Thule Force 3 M vs Yakima SkyBox NX 16 compared: Skis of 170 cm fit SkyBox but rule out the smaller Force MShort-roof hatch access, 170 cm skis, roof-load allowance and the bags you really have to carry all matter when comparing Force 3 M and SkyBox NX 16.Thule Force 3 XXL vs Yakima SkyBox NX 18 compared: Thule fits skis above 195 cm, while Yakima leaves more margin in length and payloadBefore mounting a large cargo box, weigh Force 3 XXL against SkyBox NX 18 on 205 cm skis, hatch clearance, roof-load budgets and bulky luggage.Thule Force 3 L Sport vs Thule Force 3 M compared: Sport fits longer skis alongside other gear, and M adds bag room in less lengthA bike beside the box, adult skis, soft bags, hatch access and the roof weight your car allows all shape the choice between Force 3 L Sport and Force 3 M.Thule Force 3 L Sport vs Yakima SkyBox NX 18 compared: Sport keeps neighboring rack space free, and SkyBox takes longer skis and more bagsWhen roof space has to serve bikes, longer skis or family luggage and stay within vehicle load limits, how do Force 3 L Sport and SkyBox NX 18 compare?Yakima SkyBox NX Skinny vs Thule Force 3 L Sport compared: Skinny fits longer skis and wider bars, while Sport saves more of the roof allowanceFor a bike-and-ski trip, this sets two narrow roof boxes against real ski limits, bar spacing and the weight left over for luggage.Yakima SkyBox NX Skinny vs Yakima SkyBox NX XL compared: XL gains luggage width and does not extend ski length or hatch compatibilityPick between the narrow and full-width SkyBox based on shared roof space, family bags and remaining payload, and do not assume the wider box takes longer skis.Yakima SkyBox NX XXL vs Thule Force 3 XXL compared: Yakima fits wider bar spacing, and Thule saves weight at the same ski limitTwo long-ski roof boxes, separated by fixed-bar spacing and remaining payload, with hatch measurements taken separately and honest limits for garages.Yakima SkyBox NX XXL vs Yakima SkyBox NX XL compared: Both sizes can be ruled out by long skis combined with short hatch clearanceSee whether the larger SkyBox handles long skis or bulky gear while keeping hatch access and staying under the roof weight you have left.Thule Motion 3 XL Low vs Thule Motion 3 XL compared: Low helps with overhead clearance but does not fix a short roof or hatch conflictGarage headroom and suitcase clearance come first when choosing a low roof box. Ski length and hatch threshold are the same for both.Thule Motion 3 XL Low vs Thule Force 3 L Sport compared: Low fits longer skis and Sport saves bar space, though a tight hatch can rule out bothLong skis against shared roof space is the tradeoff here, with hatch clearance, crossbar width and garage height each checked on their own.SportRack Sidekick vs Thule Force 3 M compared: Above 40 mph, Sidekick requires a 50 lb minimum load, while Force suits light bulkA compact roof box set against a larger dual-opening one, with attention to the Sidekick’s unusual highway load restriction.SportRack Sidekick vs Yakima SkyBox NX Skinny compared: The shorter shell of Sidekick saves little bar width and comes with a highway load minimumA compact passenger-opening carrier set against a long, narrow ski box, with highway load limits and shared roof space taken into account.

Best picks for one job

The best roof box for a family of fourAt 21 cubic feet, Thule Motion 3 XXL has the most verified volume in this set, as long as the roof and hatch can handle its size and weight.The best roof box for long skisMotion 3 XXL Low gives the best mix of long-ski capacity and low profile, since it takes 215 cm skis and rises 13 inches above the crossbar.The best low-profile roof boxAt about 9.75 inches above the crossbar, INNO Wedge 660 is the lowest verified option here.The best roof box for a short hatchbackAt 55.1 inches, INNO Ridge is the shortest shell, though only a manufacturer fit guide and an open-hatch measurement can confirm that it matches your vehicle.The best roof box with dual-side openingFor 18 cubic feet and 200 cm skis with opening on both sides, Thule Force 3 XL is the balanced choice.The best narrow roof box beside a bike rackAt 21 inches, SportRack Horizon Alpine is the narrowest, which gives it the best mathematical chance of leaving space for another carrier beside it.Which roof cargo box is lightest in this setAt 20 pounds, INNO Ridge is the lightest verified box here.Which roof cargo box is largest in this setBy published volume, Thule Motion 3 XXL is ahead at 21 cubic feet.The best roof box for occasional road tripsThule Pulse 2 M strikes the easiest balance for occasional use, with a weight of 31 pounds and tool-free PowerClick clamps.The best roof box to move between two carsPulse 2 L is the practical pick for switching cars, pairing a 35.3-pound shell with tool-free PowerClick mounting.The best roof box for tall luggageAt 17 inches, Rhino-Rack MasterFit 530 has the tallest verified internal height here.The best roof box for a wide crossbar spreadYakima DeepSpace 10 takes the widest-set bars in this group, at 32 to 46 inches. When your spread falls between 24 and 40 inches and you want more cargo volume, pick SkyBox NX 18. When it is 21.7 to 39.4 inches and long ski capacity suits you better, pick MasterFit 530.